Teacher Practical Guidance:
Bullying Impact
Category: Student
Rank Order
Effect Size
Achievement Gain %
How-To Strategies
Elements of Effective Anti-Bullying Programs:
- Implementing with fidelity evidence-based programs (Olweus Anti-Bullying Program Second Step; Positive Actions; Capturing Kids Hearts; Facing History)
- All staff training in evidence-based programs
- All student training
- Allowing students to be involved in bullying prevention efforts has a great impact. Students feel empowered by being directly involved in analyzing bullying issues, creating ideas to help solve the problem, and enact creative solutions. Student-led bullying prevention initiatives give students self-efficacy and a sense of agency with leadership (Shriberg et al., 2017).
- Parent meetings
- A community-wide effort shows students that adults care what happens to them and that they are not alone
- Clear discipline policies and procedures
- Social skills training
- Counseling
- Peer-peer mediation
- Youths’ resilience is a protective factor in mitigating the negative effects of bullying. Resilience is one’s ability to spring back, rebound, and successfully cope with bullying victimization. Resilience is fostered with supportive environments, positive peer relationships, a sense of belonging, and self-efficacy (Hinduja & Patchin, 2017).
- Emotional and mindfulness programs
- “Bystander” training and expectations
- Data analysis
Bullying Program Impact Effect-Size Data:
- Teaching self-control (0.87 effect size)
- Bystander intervention (0.61 effect size)
- Reducing non-compliant behaviors (0.42 effect size)
- Use of clear consequences (0.41 effect size)
- Reducing aggressive behaviors (0.34 effect size)
- Programs most effective in elementary schools
- According to the (Center for Disease Control) , promising elements of bullying prevention programs include:
-
- Multi-tiered systems of support, which includes universal programs or activities for all youth within the community or school; selective interventions for groups of youth at risk for being involved in bullying; and preventive interventions tailored for students already involved in bullying.
-
- Multicomponent programs that address multiple aspects of bullying behavior and the environments that support it. Examples include examining school rules and using behavior management techniques and social emotional learning in the classroom and throughout the school to detect and provide consequences for bullying.
-
- School-wide prevention activities that include improving the school climate, strengthening supervision of students, and having a school-wide anti-bullying policy.
-
- Involving families and communities by helping caregivers learn how to talk about bullying and get involved with school-based prevention efforts.
-
- Developing long-term school-wide approaches that strengthen youth’s social-emotional, communication, and problem-solving skills.
-
- Focusing on program fidelity by forming an implementation team to make sure the programs are carried out exactly as they were designed.
How-To Resources
Link – Program (Olweus) Bullying prevention program
Link – Program (Blueprints for Youth Dev) Olweus Bullying Prevention Program
Link – Video (Facebook Video) Dan Olweus on Bullying
Link – Program (Flippen) “Capturing Kids Hearts”
Link – Program (Blueprints) “Positive Actions”
Link – Program (Committee for Children) Second Step
Link – Videos (Anti-Bullying Alliance) 153 videos
Link – Program (CO) Bully prevention in PBIS
Link – Program ( Facing History & Ourselves) Anti-bullying program
Link – Resources (PA) Evidence based bullying prevention programs
Link – Video (We are teachers) 20 best anti-bullying videos to show students
References
Chen, C. (2020) Association between school climate and bullying victimization: Advancing integrated perspectives. School Psychology, 35(5). Link
Ferguson, C. (2007). The effectiveness of school-based anti-bullying programs: Meta-analysis. Criminal Justice Review, 32(4). Link
Fraguas, D. (2021) Assessment of school anti-bullying interventions: Meta-analysis. JMA, 175(1). Link
Lee, S., et al (2015). Meta-analysis of the effect of school-based anti-bullying programs. Journal of Child Health. 19(2). Link
Olweus, D., et al (2018). Evaluation of the Olweus bullying prevention program: A large scale study of students in grades 3-11. Journal of School Psychology, 69. Link
Bullying Impact
DEFINITIONS
DATA
-
5 meta-analysis reviews
-
81 research studies
-
290,000 students in research studies
-
3 Confidence level. Hattie (2023) p. 183
5 meta-analysis reviews
81 research studies
290,000 students in research studies
3 Confidence level. Hattie (2023) p. 183
FACTS ON BULLYING:
-
According to the Center for Disease Control, students who are bullied are more likely to experience low self-esteem and isolation, perform poorly in school, have few friends in school, have a negative view of school, experience physical symptoms (such as headaches, stomachaches, or problems sleeping), and to experience mental health issues (such as depression, suicidal thoughts, and anxiety).
-
Bullying affects witnesses as well as targets. Witnesses are more likely to use tobacco, alcohol, or other drugs; have increased mental health problems; and miss or skip school.
-
Youth who bully others are at increased risk for substance use, academic problems, and experiencing violence later in adolescence and adulthood. Youth who bully others and are bullied themselves suffer the most serious consequences and are at greater risk for mental health and behavioral problems.
-
Any student can exhibit bullying behavior – male or female, popular or unpopular, students with good grades, and those who struggle academically. Teachers need to focus on a student’s behavior, not their profile, when determining if bullying occurred.
-
Students can have multiple roles: they can be the one subjected to bullying and the one who bullies (StopBullying.gov, 2016 ). Strategies that focus on holding students accountable for their behavior – but also empower them to change that behavior – are more effective than punitive punishments and peer mediation in bullying situations.
-
In conflict, children self-monitor their behavior and generally stop when they realize they are hurting someone. When bullying, children continue their behavior when they realize it is hurting someone, and are satisfied by a feeling of power and control.
QUOTES
“Bullying is all about control as the bully aims to confront via deliberate attacking and intentionally depriving the other of self-regulation, self-control, and self-respect.” Ferguson (2007)
