Character Programs

DEFINED

---

Character education: Includes activities and experiences aiming to foster positive character development and the associated core ethical values.

 

 

BENEFITS

---

• Improved academic achievement — higher grades and standardized test scores, with the strongest effects in reading and math; a meta-analysis of 52 studies found a positive association between character education and achievement, with effects holding across ethnicity and socioeconomic status.  ac+1

 

• Schools with character education accreditation show better academic progress and school climate with no evidence of an academic opportunity cos. tandfonline

 

• Behavior & Discipline-  Fewer suspensions, discipline referrals, and dropouts. files.eric.ed

 

• Increased self-control and reduced disruptive behavior. jubileecentre.ac

 

• Reduced bullying, aggression, and violence. rdw.rowan

 

• Decreased risky behaviors such as drug use. journal.uny.ac

 

• Social-emotional development: Improved emotional competency, moral judgment, and socio-moral cognitive development. journal.uny.ac

 

• Stronger prosocial behavior, empathy, and conflict-resolution skills. files.eric.ed

 

• Better peer and teacher-student relationships. ijssbulletin

 

• School climate: Improved school culture, feelings of safety, and sense of belonging. journal.uny.ac

 

• Higher attendance and student engagement. Yale Medicine

 

• Greater student motivation and school commitment. countyhealthrankings

 

• Higher high school graduation rates and increased college attendance. steinhardt.nyu

 

• Benefits persist for years — longitudinal research shows better social relationships and fewer health and legal problems up to 18 years later. apa

 

 

 

HOW TO

---

• Model the character you teach — teachers act as caregivers, models, and mentors; students mirror the kindness, fairness, and integrity that adults show. Link

 

• Build a shared language of character — define core values (respect, honesty, responsibility) with students, post them, and use them consistently across lessons and interactions. jubileecentre.ac

 

• Be intentional and proactive, not reactive — deliberately plan character development into lessons and routines rather than waiting for teachable moments. eric.ed

 

• Create a democratic classroom — involve students in setting rules, making decisions, and shaping the classroom community. ascd

 

• Use morning meetings or community circles — regular gatherings where students express thoughts, resolve conflicts, practice empathy, and give one another compliments.

 

• Practice moral discipline — treat rule enforcement as a chance to build moral reasoning and voluntary compliance, not just obedience. ascd

 

• Co-create a class code of behavior — develop agreements that both students and teacher sign onto. mobile.collierschools

 

• Teach values explicitly and directly — students should hear the words, learn their meanings, identify the behaviors, and practice applying them; purposeful direct instruction beats incidental exposure. ascd

 

• Integrate character into academic content — use literature, history, and current events to examine ethical dilemmas and moral questions; ask “What would you have done?” about characters and historical figures.

 

• Use cooperative learning — team projects build perspective-taking, appreciation of others, and working toward common goals. ascd

 

• Employ varied methods — discussions, role-play, simulations, debates on moral dilemmas, storytelling, and project-based learning help students internalize values.

 

• Teach conflict resolution — give students concrete skills for solving conflicts fairly and without force. ascd

 

• Provide opportunities for moral action — service learning, peer mentoring, tutoring, and community projects let students practice character in real situations tandfonline

 

• Encourage reflection and self-assessment — reflective journals, goal-setting, and student self-evaluation of character growth.

 

• Foster intrinsic motivation — nurture internalization of values rather than relying on extrinsic rewards; avoid over-reliance on prizes for good behavior. tandfonline

 

• Use habituation and consistent routines — regular daily practices reinforce values until they become habits. ejournal.papanda

 

• Catch and name good character — call out and reinforce character traits whenever they appear in books, history, or student behavior. edutopia

 

 

 

WHAT MAKES PROGRAMS EFFECTIVE

 

 

CHALLENGES

---

• Competing demands on curriculum time — emphasis on testing and academic performance is identified as one of the main obstacles to creating space for character education. atlantis-press

 

• Teacher preparation gaps — teachers rarely receive specialized training, and lack pedagogical skill and guidelines for integrating character into lessons.

 

• Insufficient resources — limited resources, staffing, and supervision are major structural barriers to comprehensive implementation. al-afkar

 

• Family and community alignment — low parental involvement, differing parenting styles, and weak school–family collaboration are repeatedly cited obstacles. Link

 

• Measurement difficulty — character growth is subjective and difficult to measure; most studies lack validated measures. Link

 

• Mixed evidence of effectiveness — the largest federal evaluation found no evidence the seven programs studied improved student outcomes. Link

 

• Disagreement over core values — the field has no consensus definition of character or which values to teach. Link

 

• Risk of rewarding conformity — “forced formality” approaches target compliance with rules rather than developing students of strong, independent character. files.eric.ed

 

• Overlooking structural influences — the “fix-the-kid” approach treats problems as residing in individuals while ignoring structural drivers of behavior. scispace

 

• Low-quality program design — “cheerleading,” “praise and reward,” and “define and drill” approaches aim for quick behavioral results rather than genuine understanding and commitment. files.eric.ed

 

• Lecture-only delivery — programs built on a “transmittal” theory rely on exhortation and rewards instead of helping students internalize values. scispace

 

• Reliance on isolated lessons — effective character education requires a comprehensive, whole-school approach woven into all phases of school life, not stand-alone lessons. edweek

 

 

 

 

WHAT NOT TO DO

---

• Don’t run “cheerleading” programs — posters, banners, value-of-the-month assemblies, and upbeat announcements expose students to messages but don’t build commitment. files.eric.ed

 

• Don’t rely on “praise and reward” — catching students being good and trading chits for prizes makes the reward the focus and erodes intrinsic motivation; rewarding virtue can actually decrease students’ intrinsic commitment to it.

 

• Don’t “define and drill” — quizzing students on value definitions like multiplication facts equates memorization with the far more complex capacity to act on values.files.eric.ed

 

• Don’t use “forced formality” — strict uniform compliance with rules of conduct (walking in lines, formal address, standing when adults enter) aims at quick behavioral results, not deep and enduring effects.files.eric.ed

 

• Don’t lecture or moralize — direct instruction in moral principles has little effect; instead engage students in discussion and reflection so they understand values “from the inside out”

 

• Don’t be reactive — waiting for teachable moments rather than deliberately planning character development into lessons and routines is less effective than being intentional and proactive. edweek

 

• Don’t rely on stand-alone lessons — isolated lessons or slogans don’t work; character must be woven into every phase of school life through a comprehensive, whole-school approach. edweek

 

• Don’t reduce discipline to obedience — treating rule enforcement as only compliance misses the chance to build moral reasoning and voluntary commitment. scispace

 

• Don’t overcomplicate materials — straightforward, simple curriculum materials are far more likely to be taught consistently. edweek

 

• Don’t try to “fix the kid” — problems don’t rest solely within individuals; scrutinize the classroom and school structures (e.g., competitive systems that foster cheating) rather than remaking the students. scispace

 

• Don’t assume a dark view of human nature — programs premised on children needing to be controlled into virtue rely on indoctrination rather than developing students as thinkers about values. scispace

 

• Don’t promote uncritical deference to authority — defining values like obedience and respect in ways that demand conformity confuses morality with compliance. scispace

 

• Don’t leave students passive — the best approaches enlist students as active participants in creating a caring and just classroom community, not as recipients of adult-imposed values. files.eric.ed