Teacher Practical Guidance:
Visual Models (Concept Mapping)
Category: Strategy
Rank Order
Effect Size
Achievement Gain %
How-To Strategies
BENEFITS
- Representations” are external stand‑ins for ideas: pictures, diagrams, graphs, equations, stories, manipulatives, gestures, simulations etc.
- They matter because learners cannot directly “see” abstract structures, so representations give something concrete to inspect, manipulate, and talk about.
-
Making invisible structures and processes visible (e.g., particle diagrams for gas laws, number lines for integers).
-
Providing shared reference points that support explanation, argument, and feedback in classrooms.
- Dual coding: When information is encoded both verbally and visually, learners form two linked traces, increasing the chances of recall and comprehension.
- Multimedia learning: Well‑designed visuals plus words help learners select, organize, and integrate information into coherent mental models.
- Because visuals and language rely on partly separate cognitive channels, aligned representations can carry more meaning without overloading one channel.
- Spatial organization (e.g., a labelled diagram or concept map) lets learners see relationships at a glance instead of holding many relations in working memory.
- Diagrams, graphs, and models foster analog mental models of structures and processes, which can then be verbalized and mathematized.
- Crucially, learning deepens when students translate among representations (e.g., graph ↔ equation ↔ story).
- Learner‑generated diagrams or drawings tend to emphasize causal or functional features when students aim to explain, which can sharpen understanding of mechanisms.
- Externalized representations allow teachers and peers to diagnose misconceptions and provide targeted feedback, supporting conceptual change and self‑regulation. link
HOW TO
- Keep visuals simple and schematic, focusing on structure rather than decoration.
- Pair the visual and verbal at the same time and in close proximity (on the board, slide, or page).
- Avoid redundancy overload: do not read long blocks of text that are already on the slide alongside a complex diagram.
- Live sketching: While explaining a concept, draw a diagram, timeline, or simple flow chart as you talk.
- Graphic organizers with explanation: Use concept maps, tables, and Venn diagrams alongside short phrases or sentence stems, modeling how to encode relationships both visually and verbally.
- Dual‑coded notes: Ask students to divide pages into “words” and “pictures,” writing brief cues on one side and quick sketches, arrows, or schemas on the other.
- Visual vocabulary: For key terms, have students create a term, a one‑line definition, and a concrete image, icon, or mini‑scene capturing the meaning.
- Quick‑draw exit tickets: At the end of a lesson, students draw a simple image or diagram that represents a core idea and add a brief caption.
- Flow charts
- Diagrams
- Timelines
- Cartoon strips
- Drawing
- Posters
- Tables
- Graphic organizers
- Knowledge maps
- Advance organizers
- Posters
- Flip charts
- Photos
- Physical materials
- Infographics
- Students create their own visual representations
- 4 Step Process: Question / Draw / Explain / Label link
HOW TO Create Concept Map
Step 1 – Identify the main concept: Choose the central topic or idea that you want to explore and represent in the concept map.
Step 2 – Identify related concepts: Brainstorm and identify the key concepts, ideas, or terms related to the main concept.
Step 3 – Organize the concepts: Arrange the related concepts around the main concept and connect them using lines or arrows to show their relationships.
Step 4 – Add details and relationships: Write words or phrases along the lines to explain the relationship between the connected concepts.
Step 5 – Fine-tune the map: Review and refine the concept map to ensure it effectively represents the relationships between the concepts.
There is no right or wrong way to make a concept map, but the key step is to focus on the ways ideas are linked to each other. It’s important to limit the amount of information on the map to avoid frustration and to encourage students to continue adding to and refining the map as they learn more. O’day & Karpicke (2021)
EFFECT SIZE DATA Subject area Impact
- Humanities – 1.93
- Construct map out of class – 1.46
- Middle School – 1.18
- Retaining central ideas – 0.98
- Individual creation of map – 0.94
- Group construction of map – 0.86
- Science retain impact – 0.85
- High School – 0.72
- In-class creation of map – 0.57. Nesbit (2006)
CHALLENGES & WHAT NOT TO DO
- When poorly designed (dense slides, decorative clip art, misaligned images), representations add extraneous load and can hurt learning.
- Cognitive Overload: Combining words and visuals increases total information students must process at once; too many elements or too rapid pacing overloads working memory.
- Pace: Learners may struggle to attend to both codes simultaneously; if they are processing a complex diagram while listening to speech, one channel often “drops.”
- When images do not closely match the verbal message, students form disconnected verbal and visual traces, which weakens learning.
- Decorative clip art, generic icons, or multiple unrelated pictures compete for attention, clutter working memory, and can reduce learning. link
How-To Resources
ARTICLE
Link – ARTICLE (Venngage) 10 types of visual aides
Link – ARTICLE (UNC) Concept Maps
Link – ARTICLE (Eye) Marzano 9: Non-linguistic
Link – ARTICLE (EducWeek) Reading and Writing like a Scientist
Link – ARTICLE / VIDEO (Reading Rockets) Concept Maps
Link – ARTICLE / VIDEO (Teacher Toolkit) Concept Map
Link – ARTICLE (VariQuest) Importance of visual aids in teaching
Link – ARTICLE (Room to Discover) Guide to teaching math w/visual models
Link – ARTICLE (StructuralLearning) Dual coding
Link – ARTICLE (Kaplan) Visual aides and cognitive theory
Link – ARTICLE (BrainCamp) The importance of connecting multiple representations
Link – ARTICLE (EducationCorner) What is dual coding?
Link – ARTICLE (3rdSpace) Dual coding
Link – ARTICLE (Taylor) Putting dual coding into practice
Link – ARTICLE (Wagon) Beyond icons
Link – ARTICLE (InnerDrive) 6 common dual coding mistakes
Link – ARTICLE (Didau) Dual coding delusion
Link – ARTICLE (AALS) Best digital tools for dual coding
RESEARCH / REPORT
Link – REPORT (Hattie) Concept Mapping
VIDEO
Link – ARTICLE / VIDEO (ORIGO) Visual model in math: early elementary
Link – VIDEO (YouTube) Teach better, learn better with dual coding
Link – VIDEO (YouTube) Dual coding
Link – VIDEO (YouTube) 5 dual coding lessons
Link – VIDEO (YouTube) The secrets of dual coding
DIGITAL
Whiteboard & Sketching tools:
- Canva Whiteboard (online whiteboard and drawing tools) lets you sketch diagrams, timelines, and concept maps while adding short text labels or equations on a shared canvas.
- iDroo (real‑time collaborative whiteboard) supports freehand drawing, math notation, and quick diagramming alongside typed notes for synchronous lessons.
- myViewBoard is a classroom oriented digital whiteboard for mixing handwriting, images, text boxes, and multimedia in one space, ideal for modeling dual‑coded explanations live.
Slide and resource creation tools:
- Standard presentation tools like PowerPoint and Keynote support dual coding when used with sparse text, deliberate icons, and simple diagrams rather than dense bullet lists.
- Canva presentation and graphic templates make it easy to build consistent icon sets, flowcharts, and labeled diagrams paired with brief phrases for handouts or slides.
Note‑taking and sketchnoting apps:
- Tablet note apps such as GoodNotes or Notability
- Document camera setups like HUE HD Pro
Flashcards:
- Flashcard systems such as Quizlet, Anki, or Flashcards Deluxe
Multimedia:
- Video and screen‑recording tools (e.g., Loom, Screencastify) support narrated drawing or slide annotation.
CMap: A PC-based tool that allows users to create nodes and connecting lines by simply clicking and dragging. It enables the creation of concept maps with labels, images, roll-over notes, and hyperlinks. Maps can be saved locally or uploaded to a CMapTools server for collaboration. Link – SOFTWARE (CMap) CMap
MindMeister: A cloud-based tool that allows the creation of nodes and connecting lines by simply clicking and dragging. It also enables the hiding or revealing of any branch and sub-branch of the concept map, making it suitable for very large or complex concept maps. Link – SOFTWARE (MindMeister) MindMeister
Lucidchart: A platform that provides a guide on how to make a concept map and offers a collaborative and visual approach to creating concept maps. It allows users to draw concept maps easily using drag-and-drop shapes, flexible lines, and real-time collaboration. Link – SOFTWARE (Lucidchart) LucidChart
Other options: There are several other tools available, such as Bubbl.us, FreeMind, Google Docs, Mindomo, and Mindmup, which offer online, open-source, or free versions for creating concept maps
References
Adesope & Nesbit (2005). Verbal redundancy in multimedia learning environments: A meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology.
Berney & Betrancourt (2016). Does animation enhance learning? A meta-analysis.Computers and Education.
Kablan, Topan, & Erkan (2013). The effectiveness level of material use in classroom instruction: A meta-analysis study. Educational Sciences: Theory and Practice.
Karpicke, J., & Blunt, J. (2011). Retrieval practice produces more learning than elaborative studying with concept mapping. Science, 331(6018). Link
Lee & Huang (2008). Visual Input Enhancement and Grammar Learning: A Meta-Analytic Review. Studies in Second Language Acquisition.
Levine & Lentz (1982). Effects of text illustrations: A review of research. Educational Communication and Technology Journal.
Mainali, B. (2021). Representation in teaching and learning mathematics. International Journal of Education in Mathematics, Science, and Technology (IJEMST), 9(1), 1-21.
Mnguni LE. (2014). The theoretical cognitive process of visualization for science education. Springerplus.10;3:184.
Nesbit, J., Adescope, O. (2006). Learning with concept and knowledge maps: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 76 Link
O’day & Karpicke (2021). Comparing and combining retrieval practice and concept mapping. Journal of Educational Psychology, 113 (5). Link
Readence & Moore (1981). A meta-analytic review of the effect of adjunct pictures on reading comprehension. Psychology in the Schools.
Richter, Scheiter, & Eitel (2016). Signaling text-picture relations in multimedia learning: A comprehensive meta-analysis. Educational Research Review.
Schroeder & Cenkci (2018). Spatial contiguity and spatial split-attention effects in multimedia learning environments: a meta-analysis. Education Psychological Review.
Visual Models (Concept Mapping)
DEFINITIONS
Visual Models: Visual models are effective tools used in teaching to enhance student interest, comprehension, and retention of information. They help establish, explain, connect, and associate ideas and concepts, making the learning process more interesting and effective.
Visual aids are particularly important in teaching math, as they play a significant role in increasing student engagement and achievement. They are powerful tools for developing conceptual understanding and can be used to teach mathematics facts and help students learn mathematics content. Visual representations and modeling are also valuable in teaching, as they provide a starting point for explaining and practicing concepts.
Overall, visual models are important in teaching as they help make the learning process more engaging, enjoyable, and effective, particularly in subjects like math where they play a crucial role in conceptual understanding and problem-solving.
Concept Mapping: Concept mapping in teaching refers to the use of visual organizers to represent and organize knowledge, helping students understand the relationships between different concepts. These maps can take the form of charts, graphic organizers, tables, flowcharts, Venn Diagrams, timelines, or T-charts. They are especially useful for students who learn better visually, as they help in chunking information based on meaningful connections and seeing the big picture. Concept maps can be used to help students organize new information, make meaningful connections between ideas, and deepen their understanding and comprehension.
DATA
-
16 Meta Analysis reviews
-
1,400 Research studies
-
36,000 Students in studies
-
5 Confidence level link
QUOTES
“When teachers provide pre-made visual / concept maps the effect on student learning is lower than when teachers and students work together to create visual cues and concept maps.” Hattie (2023) p. 65
“Vision is a great attention getter and more powerful than hearing. If students are to grasp instructions, and communication from the teacher they will benefit from multi-sensory approaches. Memory is more accurate and retained longer when learning is multi-sensory.” Mattos (2016) p. 31
“One of the key success factors is to involve the students in developing the maps; not necessarily at the very beginning of the lessons, but after they have started to learn some of the subject matter vocabulary and exposure to the main ideas.” Nesbit (2006)
“Concept maps and visual models provide the ‘coat-hanger’ for students to understand the big ideas underlying the many content details.” Karpicke & Blunt (2011)
The saying that a picture is worth a thousand words has stood the test of time. Scientists agree and there is also a wealth of evidence to back up this expression. Put simply, visuals matter – a lot. link
Illustrations and other representations (graphs, diagrams, symbols, models, gestures, physical manipulatives, etc.) facilitate learning by helping learners build and coordinate mental models, reduce cognitive load, and create more retrieval routes for understanding and remembering ideas. link
